Rob Peters asks why Michael Vaughan's word should be considered more truthful than AB de Villiers's?
Dilshan makes history
Article By:
Sri Lanka batsman Tillakaratne Dilshan became the first player to
take advantage of cricket's new trial laws and successfully challenge
an on-field umpire's decision.
Dilshan was initially given out by umpire Mark Benson, adjudged
caught behind off a Zaheer Khan delivery on the second day of the test
against India.
In the past, a batsman would have had no choice but to accept the
umpire's verdict, but new laws being trialled in this test allow teams
to refer on-field decisions to a third umpire under a challenge system.
Dilshan made a "T" signal with his hands to indicate a challenge,
and third umpire Rudi Koertzen reviewed replays and ruled Dilshan not
out. Replays suggested his bat hit the ground rather than ball to
create the sound that prompted the India appeal.
Earlier, during the morning session, India captain Anil Kumble made
the first-ever challenge when an appeal for lbw against Sri Lanka
opener Malinda Warnapura was
turned down, but he was unsuccessful in
changing the original call. Koertzen upheld the on-field umpire's
decision, adjudging that the ball would have missed leg stump.
This test marks the beginning of the International Cricket Council's
experimentation with the challenge system.
In addition to the existing use of the third umpire to rule on run
outs and stumpings, players will now be able to challenge the likes of
lbw verdicts — the trickiest and most subjective of all umpiring
decisions — and catches.
Each side is allowed three challenges in each innings and the number
of challenges remains intact if a decision is overturned using the
system.