US gay couples are paying thousands of dollars to have surrogate mothers carry their babies.
Controversial letter released
Article By:
Fri, 09 May 2008 16:13
The Ginwala hearing has made public a controversial letter from
President Thabo Mbeki to Justice Minister Brigitte Mabandla over the
handling of a warrant to arrest police chief Jackie Selebi.
"Since it was in the public domain and since it had been used, there
could be no privilege that could attach to the letter," Dr Frene
Ginwala told journalists on Friday.
Ginwala is chairing the inquiry into the fitness of Vusi Pikoli to
hold the office of National Director of Public Prosecutions.
She was speaking after adjourning the oral hearings until 23 June and setting them down until 4 July at a venue yet to be announced.
On Thursday, Ginwala directed that "no public disclosure" be made of
Mbeki's letter dated 17 September.
"This is because the inquiry is internal in nature," she said.
"Obviously parts that have been read into the record, that is open
and can be referred to."
However, the inquiry made the entire contents of
the letter
available to the media on Friday.
Ginwala said she had asked the president's legal team for the letter
and inquired whether it was indeed privileged. She received a copy on
Thursday.
In a written explanation of her decision to release the letter to
the public, Ginwala told the justice department it "did not indicate in
the covering letter that there was any restriction to the disclosure of
the contents of the letter".
"Parts of the letter were referred to in evidence. I subsequently
received a verbal communication that the government would want to claim
privilege. I ruled that the letter should not be distributed, which
ruling was not opposed by either party.
"Parts of the letter were read into the record.
"I am of the considered view that no privilege still attaches to the
letter and for that reason it may be made public."
Ginwala said she had made it clear that the new direction she had
given regarding the
letter did not set any precedent relating to
disclosure of communication between members of the Cabinet and the
president.
"So it has no bearing on whatever the positions may be, but it was a
ruling applicable to that particular letter and the particular
circumstances."
In the letter, Mbeki writes:
"Dear Minister,
"I have been informed that the National Director of Public
Prosecutions has taken legal steps to effect the arrest of and the
preference of charges against the National Commission of the police
service.
"As you are aware, our constitution and legal framework recognises
that the prosecution of offenders is pursued by the prosecuting
authority on behalf of the State, represented by our duly elected
government.
"Accordingly, clause 179(6) of our constitution provides that the
Cabinet member responsible for the administration of justice must
exercise final responsibility over the prosecuting authority.
"Section
33(1) of the National Prosecuting Authority Act repeats
this constitutional directive. This Act goes further, in section 33(2),
to provide, among others, that the National Director of Public
Prosecution shall, at the request of the Minister of Justice, furnish
the Minister with information with regard to any case, matter or
subject dealt with by the National Director or a Director.
"The National Commissioner is appointed by and accountable to the
President of South Africa.
"In view of the constitutional responsibilities of the President
with regard to the Office of the National Commissioner of the police
service, I deem it appropriate that you obtain the necessary
information from the National Director of Public Prosecution regarding
the intended arrest and prosecution of the National Commissioner.
"This would enable me to make such informed decisions as may be
necessary with regard to the National Commissioner.
"Kindly keep me informed of
progress in this regard. Needless to
say, this matter is urgent."